Sandwiches in Chicago Loop

Cheese-filled sandwiches at Gayle V's Best Ever Grilled Cheese in Chicago Loop, IL pair savory fillings with spreads for pickup.

Order online

Popular Sandwiches to Try

Classic

$8.50

Butterkäse grilled cheese on white sourdough with fresh butter.

“I got the classic sammich and won some cheese curds on National Grilled Cheese day, all were delicious! The staff were very friendly. I highly recommend this!!”

Duke

$13.00

Grilled cheese with Swiss, ham, and your choice of mustard or jam.

“Great cheese sandwiches, highly recommended”

Little Italy

$12.00

Butterkäse, garlic spread, tomato salsa, and pepperoni fill this sandwich.

“I had one of their gluten free grilled cheeses from their stand at the farmers market, 10/10 it was absolutely delicious!!!”

Prepared the Gayle V's Best Ever Grilled Cheese Way

Gayle V's Best Ever Grilled Cheese serves sandwiches with fillings ranging from egg and chorizo to Buffalo chicken, plus combinations featuring sautéed mushrooms or fresh tomato and house-made basil pesto.

Duke pairs Swiss cheese and ham with mustard or jam. The Jake combines Gouda, ham and apple butter, while Abreo layers white cheddar with bacon onion jam and slices of Honeycrisp apples.

Join us in Chicago Loop, IL for dine-in, or order pickup or delivery. Classic pairs Butterkäse cheese with fresh-baked white sourdough bread and fresh butter; you can add bacon or tomato and basil feta.

Sandwiches to Try

Blue Buffalo

Grilled cheese with Butterkäse, Buffalo chicken, and blue cheese.

“The grilled cheeses here are always fantastic, and the staff are superb.”

Gobbler

A melted cheese sandwich grilled between slices of bread.

“Excellent sandwich. Out of the way in the lower level of Block 37, so you might miss it if you're not looking for it. Lots of interesting grilled cheese combos. I did the Gobbler which had turkey and cheddar. Everything was cooked fresh and quickly.”

Margarita

Grilled cheese with Butterkäse, nut-free basil pesto, and fresh tomato.

“I had the Margherita with the tomato dip soup and it was delicious, I'm craving it all the time now”

River Valley

Grilled cheese with Swiss, sautéed mushrooms, and smoked onion marmalade.

“Gayle reminds me of the Jeni Britton Bauer (Jeni's Ice Creams) of the sandwich art. I watched both of them coming up, and they share the same genes. Gayle is always hustling, she invests herself in her business, and she's always inventing new and clever flavor combinations. Gayle V's is a hidden favorite in the Pedway that the locals know and love. I tried the lobster melt today - good LORD that's good.”

Southport

Butterkäse and smoked onion marmalade fill this grilled cheese sandwich.

“Found this place while exploring the pedways. What a treat! The southport was very tasty. We also got the mac which was good, but glad we only got the little. It was just enough.”

Abreo

$13.00

White cheddar, bacon-onion jam, and apple fill this grilled cheese.

“Amazing. Kelly made it easy to order and the food came out quick. Absolutely, hands down, best grilled cheeses.”

Breakfast Box Combo

$18.00

A breakfast grilled cheese sandwich comes with seasonal mixed fruit.

“Gayle V’s never disappoints! Their grilled cheeses and Mac and cheese are unmatched and the staff is always so friendly! Just be ware if you have allergies that the tomato soup has pesto/pine nuts”

Breakfast Club #1

$15.00

Grilled cheese with double Butterkäse, pork sausage, egg, and maple syrup.

“This was my first time here. I came in with an hungry stomach and this restaurant made my experience wonderful. I ordered the Breakfast Club #1 and Chicago passion Black/Green tea. It was very delicious. There was also live feel good music. I will be visiting more often. Thank you Michelle. ❤️❤️”

Breakfast Club #2

$15.00

Grilled cheese with Swiss, turkey sausage, egg, and smoked onion marmalade.

“Gayle V’s has the best Grilled Cheese I have ever had! The workers are really nice and friendly. The grilled cheese is very delicious with the best cheese pull ever. I would highly recommend!”

Breakfast Club #3

$15.00

Grilled cheese with double white cheddar, egg, bacon, and maple syrup.

“One of the best places for an grilled cheese in the loop and city.”

Breakfast Club #4

$15.00

Egg, chorizo, cheddar, and hot sauce fill this breakfast grilled cheese.

“honestly, the best grilled cheese I've ever had! staff was absolutely amazing.”

Cheeze & Thank You

$13.00

Vegan mozzarella, basil, and tomato jam make this grilled cheese.

“They were right! Best vegan grilled cheese I have ever had in my life.”

LI - No Pep

$12.00

Grilled cheese with optional vegetables, proteins, or spreads to customize.

“My husband and I came from South Dakota and this was one of our "must try" places for our first visit to Chicago. It did not disappoint. Without a doubt the best grilled cheese we've ever had. Love how everything is locally sourced. Great food and great service. Very impressed!!! Will be back the next time we visit Chicago.”

On The Lighter Side

$12.00+

Small grilled cheese with tomato pesto soup and house-made potato chips.

“I’m always skeptical when a place says they make the best of what they’re offering. But Gayle wasn’t lying. The grilled cheese was perfect and so was the tomato soup. Don’t expect Campbell’s whatsoever. I got the “on the lighter side” which was perfect for a little bite before I headed home. So comforting. I hope they stay open forever!”

Pulled Porker

$15.00

Pulled pork, barbecue sauce, and butterkäse fill this grilled cheese.

“Great lunch atmosphere! I tried the Pulled Porker and lemonade soda and really enjoyed both!”

Pumpkin Pie Harvest Melt

$12.00

Grilled cheese with white cheddar, pumpkin pie, and Honeycrisp apple slices.

“The grilled cheese sandwiches are always on point, and this is a nice stop off point for a break between traveling and such.. I had the Abreo.. Cheddar .. bacon onion jam .. apple slices on paninni bread.. I got their home made potato chips and a Filberts soda.. didn't take too long to bring over either. good choice if you're needing a tasty bite!”

The Jake

$13.00

Gouda, ham, and apple butter fill this grilled cheese sandwich.

“Gayle V's advertises themselves as having the best cheese sandwiches ever, and I think they are right! They have many creative and delicious choices, each hand-made. They also have hand-made chips that are wonderful and a selection of bottled sodas including a lemonade soda that was very good. The environment is clean and modern. The even had live music the day I stopped by for lunch. They are on the lower level of the mall outside entrance to the subway.”

Classic Box Combo

$13.00

A catering sandwich combo with optional cheese, greens, proteins, and sauces.

“Great little sandwich shop in the pedway. One of the best grilled cheese I’ve had. The butterkase cheese is so good, I’m gonna ask for extra next time (worth the money).”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Classic — This sandwich layers Prairie Pure Butterkäse cheese in Bennison’s white sourdough, buttered with Nordic Creamery fresh butter.
River Valley — This grilled cheese features Prairie Pure Swiss cheese with sautéed River Valley mushrooms and smoked onion marmalade.
Duke — Swiss cheese and ham fill this grilled cheese sandwich, with mustard or jam selected to add a tangy or sweet spread.
Blue Buffalo — This sandwich combines house-made Buffalo chicken with Butterkäse and Prairie Pure blue cheese between grilled bread.
Little Italy — Butterkäse and five-cheese garlic spread provide the cheese and savory spread, while tomato salsa and pepperoni complete the filling.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Chicago Loop area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.